Advertisement
Meet your Special Someone
Blogs > KQRBNP > Gone with the Wind...... > Knowing the past 了解过去
Knowing the past 了解过去
KQRBNP 10/26/2008 6:42 pm
How important for you to know the past of your partner or to reveal your past to your partner in a loving relationship? How much would you reveal or know? Do you think it's going to help or hurt your relationship by revealing it or knowing it? In what way?

你认为在一段恋爱关系中,了解对方的过去或向对方讲述你的过去是否很重要?你会讲多少?又会想知道多少?你觉得这样做会对这段关系有帮助还是有伤害?会是怎样的帮助或伤害呢?



Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!
KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/20/2008 1:01 pm

    Quoting scipii:
    hi..KQ

    i agree whole heartedly about your point of view about knowing one's past can only help others get to know that person better from different perspective.(i'm not arguing just for the sake of it...i'm a "seeker of truth" ).thanks for not bombarding me..and i am glad that our view does not differ too much in this .....
Hi Scipii,

Bonbarding you? Why? Don't see the reason that I should do that. Oh, well, maybe I am just not that kind of person.

Wish you well in whatever situation you are in now.


Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

scipii
1242 posts

11/20/2008 3:49 am

    Quoting KQRBNP:
    ladies generally are more...errr.."inquisitive"....

    How about this? Probably, only probably, there are more women who would like to know more about past than men.

    Speaking about rational, I would not consider it rational if one assumes that knowing the past would help smoothing the road ahead. To me, knowing something about one's past can only help others get to know that person better from different perspectives, and they would know where the relationships would go.

hi..KQ

i agree whole heartedly about your point of view about knowing one's past can only help others get to know that person better from different perspective.(i'm not arguing just for the sake of it...i'm a "seeker of truth" ).thanks for not bombarding me..and i am glad that our view does not differ too much in this .....

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/19/2008 4:00 pm

    Quoting scipii:
    hi..KQ

    i pay special attention to this topic bcos this is something very relevant to my own situation right now.yes your were right, everyone seemed to have taken "the past" refer to past romantic relationship.(how funny...when one commemt started dwelling into it all the rest follow suit....now you mention it and i read your original post...the past does not necessary refer to past relationship..

    from my little survey, seems like ladies generally are more...errr.."inquisitive"...(some even insist upon knowing every-single-details...which is frown upon by our wise man bro DVC(whom i greatly respect and tend to agree with him on this)

    if i may add to the argument or defence of camp no2.(which seemed more rational)...世事如棋局局新.no two relationship are on the same settings and same sets of challenges.to assume that knowing the past will help to "smoothing" the road ahead could be a bit of a wishful thinking...what if that leads to openning the pandora's box..
    (弄巧反柮)..
ladies generally are more...errr.."inquisitive"....

How about this? Probably, only probably, there are more women who would like to know more about past than men.

Speaking about rational, I would not consider it rational if one assumes that knowing the past would help smoothing the road ahead. To me, knowing something about one's past can only help others get to know that person better from different perspectives, and they would know where the relationships would go.


Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

scipii
1242 posts

11/19/2008 2:23 pm

    Quoting KQRBNP:
    Scipii,

    How delightful to know that you not only follow my writings but also dig in to read some old posts and find it relevent and interesting!

    My pleasure and appreciation for you to take time to read all comments! You know, this is the process of knowing the past.

    May I ask you what was in your mind about the word past when you first read my original post? Were you immediately thinking that it referred to past romantic relationships? From what I see from everyone's comment, seemed that's what was in people's mind even you could distingush them into two groups. Then, does that all one's past has?

    Once, the guy whome I am speaking with told me that what some of his friends said about him, something not so positive, in my point of view. So, I wondered if it's true. If it's true, then why am I attracted to such kind of person? If not true, then why his friends said so? By chatting with him about his childhood, his relationship with his parents when he was young, the things he used to do, the contacts he has had, and such such....... I figured out why his friends said so. To me, knowing some of his past helps me to know how and what has shaped him.

    Basically, I'd go with truelover and Goan on this -- depending upon the person, the situation, and where the relationship stands.

hi..KQ

i pay special attention to this topic bcos this is something very relevant to my own situation right now.yes your were right, everyone seemed to have taken "the past" refer to past romantic relationship.(how funny...when one commemt started dwelling into it all the rest follow suit....now you mention it and i read your original post...the past does not necessary refer to past relationship..

from my little survey, seems like ladies generally are more...errr.."inquisitive"...(some even insist upon knowing every-single-details...which is frown upon by our wise man bro DVC(whom i greatly respect and tend to agree with him on this)

if i may add to the argument or defence of camp no2.(which seemed more rational)...世事如棋局局新.no two relationship are on the same settings and same sets of challenges.to assume that knowing the past will help to "smoothing" the road ahead could be a bit of a wishful thinking...what if that leads to openning the pandora's box..
(弄巧反柮)..

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/19/2008 12:58 pm

    Quoting scipii:
    hi..KQ

    i just discovered you posted one of the most interesting and relevent topic(when you did it, i was in Asia FriendFinder "hibernation")

    i read very carefully of all the comments from all sides in your blog and i must say i find out very "delighting" findings.

    well i sort of classified the comments into 2 camps(1)pro towards knowing the past(2)pro towards not knowing the past.

    my view?...pro towards not knowing the past.(i'm a great lover of history, but not my love ones history...)

    let see...2 guys and 6 ladies pro towards knowing the past.(yong,gotofuture,yourself,tulip,milly,yaqi,zhuli...maybe even sayu)

    7 guys(me inclucive)...(if you count truelover and goan..it would take the tally to 9 !!) namely..dxcxz,jpollock,meilejia,cgy,dvc,manhan,scipii+3 ladies..yeye,fangmeil,mayfromnow....wow...a stronger camp!!..

    to be continue.....
Scipii,

How delightful to know that you not only follow my writings but also dig in to read some old posts and find it relevent and interesting!

My pleasure and appreciation for you to take time to read all comments! You know, this is the process of knowing the past.

May I ask you what was in your mind about the word past when you first read my original post? Were you immediately thinking that it referred to past romantic relationships? From what I see from everyone's comment, seemed that's what was in people's mind even you could distingush them into two groups. Then, does that all one's past has?

Once, the guy whome I am speaking with told me that what some of his friends said about him, something not so positive, in my point of view. So, I wondered if it's true. If it's true, then why am I attracted to such kind of person? If not true, then why his friends said so? By chatting with him about his childhood, his relationship with his parents when he was young, the things he used to do, the contacts he has had, and such such....... I figured out why his friends said so. To me, knowing some of his past helps me to know how and what has shaped him.

Basically, I'd go with truelover and Goan on this -- depending upon the person, the situation, and where the relationship stands.


Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

scipii
1242 posts

11/19/2008 7:57 am

hi..KQ

i just discovered you posted one of the most interesting and relevent topic(when you did it, i was in Asia FriendFinder "hibernation")

i read very carefully of all the comments from all sides in your blog and i must say i find out very "delighting" findings.

well i sort of classified the comments into 2 camps(1)pro towards knowing the past(2)pro towards not knowing the past.

my view?...pro towards not knowing the past.(i'm a great lover of history, but not my love ones history...)

let see...2 guys and 6 ladies pro towards knowing the past.(yong,gotofuture,yourself,tulip,milly,yaqi,zhuli...maybe even sayu)

7 guys(me inclucive)...(if you count truelover and goan..it would take the tally to 9 !!) namely..dxcxz,jpollock,meilejia,cgy,dvc,manhan,scipii+3 ladies..yeye,fangmeil,mayfromnow....wow...a stronger camp!!..

to be continue.....

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/11/2008 3:43 pm

    Quoting chupo3:
    I think it is only normal for a person to be interested in their partners life experiences. After time spent with the ones you care about, you can begin to feel more comfortable and share your feelings and this will happen naturally when you tust them more over time. never tell anyone anything that they can use to hurt you or influence you in the negative.
Thanks for stopping by.

After time spent with the ones you care about, you can begin to feel more comfortable and share your feelings and this will happen naturally when you tust them more over time.

So true.

never tell anyone anything that they can use to hurt you or influence you in the negative.

Thanks for the advice!

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

chupo3
1 post 

11/11/2008 11:26 am

I think it is only normal for a person to be interested in their partners life experiences. After time spent with the ones you care about, you can begin to feel more comfortable and share your feelings and this will happen naturally when you tust them more over time. never tell anyone anything that they can use to hurt you or influence you in the negative.

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/5/2008 5:57 pm

    Quoting manhan1:
    还听说;‘他人自愿讲述的会比被询问出来的要好一点点’

    忽的闻到了糠窝头的香味再就是了解历史首先要具备一颗巨大巨慈的心否则的话还是---
再就是了解历史首先要具备一颗巨大巨慈的心

有这要求吗?好像在学校学历史时没有要求要具备一颗巨大巨慈的心。


Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

manhan1
2398 posts 

11/5/2008 3:01 pm

    Quoting KQRBNP:
    也听说,“了解历史的人知道怎样才能更好地向前。”
还听说;‘他人自愿讲述的会比被询问出来的要好一点点’

忽的闻到了糠窝头的香味再就是了解历史首先要具备一颗巨大巨慈的心否则的话还是---

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/5/2008 10:36 am

    Quoting manhan1:
    听说;‘让现在告诉未来’会比了解昨夜共有益处。
也听说,“了解历史的人知道怎样才能更好地向前。”

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/5/2008 10:33 am

    Quoting yonganzl:
    KQRBNP,
    I think you're right that it all depends.

    When I was interviewed, one common question was why I left my ex-company.

    Some monthes ago, a woman asked me whether I had a girl friend before and why we broke up. I've never asked a woman about her former relationships. I consider it private. They told me proactively, that's ok.
Just like we all have history courses in schools. Not our own history, but other countries.

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

manhan1
2398 posts 

11/4/2008 7:56 pm

听说;‘让现在告诉未来’会比了解昨夜共有益处。

yonganzl
1405 posts 

11/4/2008 1:00 am

KQRBNP,
I think you're right that it all depends.

When I was interviewed, one common question was why I left my ex-company.

Some monthes ago, a woman asked me whether I had a girl friend before and why we broke up. I've never asked a woman about her former relationships. I consider it private. They told me proactively, that's ok.

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/3/2008 5:52 pm

    Quoting yonganzl:
    KQRBNP,
    It's probably because Sayu doesn't really know men. But I don' know women either. I find Goan's comment relevant.

    Maybe we can reveal our past to our lovers selectively. I think it's inevitable that everyone wants to know his lover's past. At the same time, everyone will reveal his or her past more or less. But if you think revealing your past may harm your relationship, you can choose to hide it. It's a matter of choice. It depends on your experience, knowledge, wisdom and so on. If your lover asks your past but you don't want to say. He may get more curious and suspicious. It can also harm your relationship. Then you're between the devil and the deep sea. What will you do then? Telling a lie?
Yes, Oasis. It's a personal choice of whether you say it or not, how much you should say, and at what situation, in what way. It all depends.

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/3/2008 5:46 pm

    Quoting goannaoil:
    KQ, I think you may find that men, in general, are less inclined to talk about what they consider to be trivia. I am not saying it is trivia but it is seen that way by many. You may find that women are much the same in that they tend to talk less about the same kinds of things that men do, their intersts generally being different.

    Another generalisation - men tend to look outside the cave, women tend to look to the inside. I suppose it's an evolutionary survival trait.
Goan, I actually thought about it. But you know, some men I know do really care a lot about their ladies past. So, I am not sure if it's the culture effect or individual difference.

Not sure what makes this big and obvious difference in thinking between men and women. Social culture influence or brain structure difference? There is a book called "Sex on the Brain" by Deborah Blum, that was trying to address this. Unfortunately, our knowledge on human brain and its activities is still very limited.


Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/3/2008 5:27 pm

    Quoting davinci2rinpoche:
    As far as I remember, you're always clear, KQ, which makes it a pleasure to talk with you.

    "Have you never compared your new gf with old ones?"

    I swear I have never done so, as far as I remember, and as conscious as I may be of my behaviours and reactions. To me, the past is past, there's nothing to be regretted about it. If you do, it simply means that you are not ripe for a new relationship. As, I think Nohea's motto goes, we should only be happy that something good and enjoyable happened once, and when it's over it's over: no regret, no sorrow, no remorse. My Stoic school of philosophy has it that one must not worry about things we have no control over. Typically, we have no control over the past.

    As you know, dear KQ, power lies in information. Nowadays, powerful people are not the ones with big muscles, not even with smart brains, but the ones who KNOW what there is to know at a given moment. Be it illegal insider's info used to one's own profit, or lawful info gained by work and research.

    Now, suppose that you tell your new lover that your ex used to find fault with, say (to take a non-sensitive detail), the way you spice chicken. He might be tempted to make an ally of your ex when criticizing the way you spice chicken... Oh, I know, a funny if not silly example, but I trust you will think of much more sensitive data that can be used against you. So that's fine in the beginning, when you think you can reveal everything as proof of your love and confidence, but are you sure you will never regret it?

    Now, of course, you may reveal everything you want which does not involve ex-partners, because, whether you want it or not, the new one will find at some point that he is in a kind of competition with the former ones.

    What I call a lack of respect is any insistence on wanting to know, on trying to force the other to say very private things. The desire to "reveal" things must come from the person themselves, and must not be exacted, not even asked for.

    Oh, one more private experience (I'm afraid I tell private things to you only ). Once my US girlfriend (I was 26) told me she had a threesome, and asked me whether I would be interested. It happened I was not. If she had asked me without mentioning she had already done it, it would have been OK. The fact that I knew she had done it was a damage to the relationship. That was one "revelation" too many, although, after all, what was it but a proof of confidence?...
DVC, one more question for you.

You said you've never compared your new gf with old ones. Then, if you want to know more about a lady who has had previous relationship(s), would you ask her the reason that made her single again? If she divorced, whould you like to know why she divorced?


Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

11/3/2008 5:14 pm

    Quoting davinci2rinpoche:
    As far as I remember, you're always clear, KQ, which makes it a pleasure to talk with you.

    "Have you never compared your new gf with old ones?"

    I swear I have never done so, as far as I remember, and as conscious as I may be of my behaviours and reactions. To me, the past is past, there's nothing to be regretted about it. If you do, it simply means that you are not ripe for a new relationship. As, I think Nohea's motto goes, we should only be happy that something good and enjoyable happened once, and when it's over it's over: no regret, no sorrow, no remorse. My Stoic school of philosophy has it that one must not worry about things we have no control over. Typically, we have no control over the past.

    As you know, dear KQ, power lies in information. Nowadays, powerful people are not the ones with big muscles, not even with smart brains, but the ones who KNOW what there is to know at a given moment. Be it illegal insider's info used to one's own profit, or lawful info gained by work and research.

    Now, suppose that you tell your new lover that your ex used to find fault with, say (to take a non-sensitive detail), the way you spice chicken. He might be tempted to make an ally of your ex when criticizing the way you spice chicken... Oh, I know, a funny if not silly example, but I trust you will think of much more sensitive data that can be used against you. So that's fine in the beginning, when you think you can reveal everything as proof of your love and confidence, but are you sure you will never regret it?

    Now, of course, you may reveal everything you want which does not involve ex-partners, because, whether you want it or not, the new one will find at some point that he is in a kind of competition with the former ones.

    What I call a lack of respect is any insistence on wanting to know, on trying to force the other to say very private things. The desire to "reveal" things must come from the person themselves, and must not be exacted, not even asked for.

    Oh, one more private experience (I'm afraid I tell private things to you only ). Once my US girlfriend (I was 26) told me she had a threesome, and asked me whether I would be interested. It happened I was not. If she had asked me without mentioning she had already done it, it would have been OK. The fact that I knew she had done it was a damage to the relationship. That was one "revelation" too many, although, after all, what was it but a proof of confidence?...
Well, DVC, I don't see the connection between revealing one's past and regreting about it. Also, revealing the past has not to be the complaints about one's previous partner, not even has to be anything about one's previous relationship(s). It's like, if not the same, at least similar, we all learn history, not only about our own nation, our own country, our own race, but others as well.

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

yonganzl
1405 posts 

10/31/2008 8:46 pm

KQRBNP,
It's probably because Sayu doesn't really know men. But I don' know women either. I find Goan's comment relevant.

Maybe we can reveal our past to our lovers selectively. I think it's inevitable that everyone wants to know his lover's past. At the same time, everyone will reveal his or her past more or less. But if you think revealing your past may harm your relationship, you can choose to hide it. It's a matter of choice. It depends on your experience, knowledge, wisdom and so on. If your lover asks your past but you don't want to say. He may get more curious and suspicious. It can also harm your relationship. Then you're between the devil and the deep sea. What will you do then? Telling a lie?

goannaoil
3787 posts

10/31/2008 2:33 pm

    Quoting KQRBNP:
    Sayu, though I don't know if and why man is more reluctant to share their past, I do believe they think differently from women in love affaires. Reminds me a post I read some time ago The difference between men and women, which shows how different between man and woman.
KQ, I think you may find that men, in general, are less inclined to talk about what they consider to be trivia. I am not saying it is trivia but it is seen that way by many. You may find that women are much the same in that they tend to talk less about the same kinds of things that men do, their intersts generally being different.

Another generalisation - men tend to look outside the cave, women tend to look to the inside. I suppose it's an evolutionary survival trait.

davinci2rinpoche
4164 posts 

10/31/2008 2:08 pm

As far as I remember, you're always clear, KQ, which makes it a pleasure to talk with you.

"Have you never compared your new gf with old ones?"

I swear I have never done so, as far as I remember, and as conscious as I may be of my behaviours and reactions. To me, the past is past, there's nothing to be regretted about it. If you do, it simply means that you are not ripe for a new relationship. As, I think Nohea's motto goes, we should only be happy that something good and enjoyable happened once, and when it's over it's over: no regret, no sorrow, no remorse. My Stoic school of philosophy has it that one must not worry about things we have no control over. Typically, we have no control over the past.

As you know, dear KQ, power lies in information. Nowadays, powerful people are not the ones with big muscles, not even with smart brains, but the ones who KNOW what there is to know at a given moment. Be it illegal insider's info used to one's own profit, or lawful info gained by work and research.

Now, suppose that you tell your new lover that your ex used to find fault with, say (to take a non-sensitive detail), the way you spice chicken. He might be tempted to make an ally of your ex when criticizing the way you spice chicken... Oh, I know, a funny if not silly example, but I trust you will think of much more sensitive data that can be used against you. So that's fine in the beginning, when you think you can reveal everything as proof of your love and confidence, but are you sure you will never regret it?

Now, of course, you may reveal everything you want which does not involve ex-partners, because, whether you want it or not, the new one will find at some point that he is in a kind of competition with the former ones.

What I call a lack of respect is any insistence on wanting to know, on trying to force the other to say very private things. The desire to "reveal" things must come from the person themselves, and must not be exacted, not even asked for.

Oh, one more private experience (I'm afraid I tell private things to you only ). Once my US girlfriend (I was 26) told me she had a threesome, and asked me whether I would be interested. It happened I was not. If she had asked me without mentioning she had already done it, it would have been OK. The fact that I knew she had done it was a damage to the relationship. That was one "revelation" too many, although, after all, what was it but a proof of confidence?...

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/31/2008 12:15 pm

    Quoting sayhelltouu:
    KQ,

    I read your comments on mine and people's , I knew you are the one who is capable of clever enough to talk with people when you want to know more about their past . i trust your experience you told me . I share your ideas about knowing people's history is important reference for us to know people's personalities or qualities better .

    But ,what i was curious about is that , by reading here or somewhere else , it seemed to me that as if man is more reluctant to share their past than women did ? then i suspected that man seemed have different mind-set from women ? and it does not relate to their dishonest or don't care their women ?

    Some cases i learnt -- man complain their woman " so boring , i don't konw why so much questions women want to ask , sound like they are 十万个为什么 .." they don't seem like to be asked so much ,or perhaps , they think bygone was bygone ,just let go ,is there any meaning mention it again ?

    I just believe man is different from women in love affairs . we women should be careful to avoid don't do thing with our way based on our mind-set . but acting according the circumstance ? what idea do you have about this ?
Sayu, though I don't know if and why man is more reluctant to share their past, I do believe they think differently from women in love affaires. Reminds me a post I read some time ago The difference between men and women, which shows how different between man and woman.

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/31/2008 12:03 pm

    Quoting yonganzl:
    KQRBNP,
    I'm afraid men ( at least Chinese men ) generally mind women's past more. It seems that men are more narrow-minded and jealous in this respect. That's why most Chinese men, according to an online survey, care about whether their wives are vir9ins or not.

    Davinci,
    I agree with you at some points. Besides, I've a few different thoughts.

    When I applied a new job, the company would ask for my job experience in the past. They would ask a lot of detailed questions about what I had done and how I had done in my ex-employers. I wonder. Why can we know our lovers' occupations, age, nationalities, personality, likes and dislikes but we can't know their past? In my opinion, they are all relevant. It makes me know more about my lover, more all-sided and accurate. If my lover used to be a smoker, but now she has quitted smoking. It only shows her good qualities, such as determination, persistence, and she's willing to have a healthier lifestyle.

    Telling my past to my lover and asking my lover's past is a respect to my lover. It shows I am serious about our relationship and care about her. What's the point of hiding everything in the past as if I don't have the past?

    Moreover, it can prevent something bad happen in the future. See Truelove's example. If the man had known her lover was not a vir9in before getting married, he would have probably not married her. Also, she would have known that he was so narrow-minded and would have probably not married him. I think it would have been better to both of them.

    Just my opinion. What do you think?
Oasis, obviously, you have a quite different point of view than sayhelltouu on who cares more, in terms of man and woman. (See her comment please)

I do think that the reasonalbe revealing of one's past is necessary in getting to know each other better. How much is reasonable and relevant? As truelover88 and Goan said, it totally depends on the individual.


Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

sayhelltouu
662 posts 

10/30/2008 9:26 pm

    Quoting cgy1963:
    这个问题提得好.
    我认为1.不刻意追问,2.不刻意隐瞒,3.情之所至,事之所至,顺其自然,既往不咎.
    如果对方对我的过去有兴趣,愿意倾听,我会毫不保留,如果对方不信任或者计较,我会道一声祝福,默默走开.
    但是,我不会对对方的过去感兴趣,不会刻意去了解对方.
    我以为,了解一个人,了解其基本品质就足够了.了解基本品质其实很容易,比如,对一个人,一件事,一部作品,一种社会现象社会问题的看法,表达的就是我或她的价值取向,道德观念,理想追求,是否有责任感同情心等等.
    对人性人生有基本的正义的认同,才不会迷失.
一个人知道什么是好是坏,不等于他就能言行一致,根源于他的局限性,而一个人的历史,是真实的轨迹,根源于他的真实性.反映了他真的是谁,而非他说他自己是谁

sayhelltouu
662 posts 

10/30/2008 9:19 pm

你好, 能讲讲为什么吗?

sayhelltouu
662 posts 

10/30/2008 9:14 pm

KQ,

I read your comments on mine and people's , I knew you are the one who is capable of clever enough to talk with people when you want to know more about their past . i trust your experience you told me . I share your ideas about knowing people's history is important reference for us to know people's personalities or qualities better .

But ,what i was curious about is that , by reading here or somewhere else , it seemed to me that as if man is more reluctant to share their past than women did ? then i suspected that man seemed have different mind-set from women ? and it does not relate to their dishonest or don't care their women ?

Some cases i learnt -- man complain their woman " so boring , i don't konw why so much questions women want to ask , sound like they are 十万个为什么 .." they don't seem like to be asked so much ,or perhaps , they think bygone was bygone ,just let go ,is there any meaning mention it again ?

I just believe man is different from women in love affairs . we women should be careful to avoid don't do thing with our way based on our mind-set . but acting according the circumstance ? what idea do you have about this ?

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/30/2008 2:22 pm

    Quoting davinci2rinpoche:
    You raise an interesting question, KQ, and I was surprised that I immediately knew what my stand was, because it is not an easy one.

    I remember one of my girlfriends asking me how lovemaking was with my former gf and if it was "better" with her! Of course, such a question is so silly it can only hurt the new relationship. What is definitely damaging is any type of "competitive comparisons".

    In a new relationship we are not looking for a BETTER partner, but for a more COMPATIBLE partner. The former partner may actually be better at a lot of things, from cooking to seks, the former partner may be better-looking, earn more money, etc., but still the relationship with the new partner may be much more rewarding... So any kind of comparison between an ex and a new partner is completely irrelevant. Why then "reveal" anything?

    To selfishly come back to my latest post about owning people, wanting to know everything about our partners' ex-relationships seems to me to be an attempt at possessing the new partner, controlling them by knowing everything. In my opinion, only a person very unsure of themselves will want to know everything about her lover. It is a lack of respect.

    To some extent, I'd say we always "love" the ones we used to love, only that has turned into a different sort of love, and we cannot deny them. Suppose you had a "bad" partner, one who used to shout and drink, or whatever. Even that bad experience has shaped you into what you are now, and hopefully made you better. So even that "bad" partner played a positive role in your life...
Davinci, I think you pointed out the key point in developing a loving relationship, which is about compatability, not about how good the one is. Unfortunetely, not many people realise this, so they tend to compare with what's in the previous relationships and end up looking for pains for themselves. It is indeed silly to do this kind of comparisons, but I believe no one can for sure say they don't compare new partner with old ones. Have you never compared your new gf with old ones?

Revealing the past has not necessarily to be all about previous relationships. Anything in the past could have impacts on one's attitude toward his or her life. Why do you say "we are not looking for a BETTER partner, but for a more COMPATIBLE partner"? Because something happened to you in the past told you that this kind of comparisons "can only hurt the new relationship". I don't think knowing something (can't be everything)about someone's past is lack of respect. Maybe, if someone wants to control his/her partner, he or she may want to know as much as possible about his or her past. But by knowing someone's past does not mean one wants to control his or her partner. Hope I made myself clear here.


Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

yonganzl
1405 posts 

10/29/2008 9:23 pm

KQRBNP,
I'm afraid men ( at least Chinese men ) generally mind women's past more. It seems that men are more narrow-minded and jealous in this respect. That's why most Chinese men, according to an online survey, care about whether their wives are vir9ins or not.

Davinci,
I agree with you at some points. Besides, I've a few different thoughts.

When I applied a new job, the company would ask for my job experience in the past. They would ask a lot of detailed questions about what I had done and how I had done in my ex-employers. I wonder. Why can we know our lovers' occupations, age, nationalities, personality, likes and dislikes but we can't know their past? In my opinion, they are all relevant. It makes me know more about my lover, more all-sided and accurate. If my lover used to be a smoker, but now she has quitted smoking. It only shows her good qualities, such as determination, persistence, and she's willing to have a healthier lifestyle.

Telling my past to my lover and asking my lover's past is a respect to my lover. It shows I am serious about our relationship and care about her. What's the point of hiding everything in the past as if I don't have the past?

Moreover, it can prevent something bad happen in the future. See Truelove's example. If the man had known her lover was not a vir9in before getting married, he would have probably not married her. Also, she would have known that he was so narrow-minded and would have probably not married him. I think it would have been better to both of them.

Just my opinion. What do you think?

davinci2rinpoche
4164 posts 

10/29/2008 3:53 pm

You raise an interesting question, KQ, and I was surprised that I immediately knew what my stand was, because it is not an easy one.

I remember one of my girlfriends asking me how lovemaking was with my former gf and if it was "better" with her! Of course, such a question is so silly it can only hurt the new relationship. What is definitely damaging is any type of "competitive comparisons".

In a new relationship we are not looking for a BETTER partner, but for a more COMPATIBLE partner. The former partner may actually be better at a lot of things, from cooking to seks, the former partner may be better-looking, earn more money, etc., but still the relationship with the new partner may be much more rewarding... So any kind of comparison between an ex and a new partner is completely irrelevant. Why then "reveal" anything?

To selfishly come back to my latest post about owning people, wanting to know everything about our partners' ex-relationships seems to me to be an attempt at possessing the new partner, controlling them by knowing everything. In my opinion, only a person very unsure of themselves will want to know everything about her lover. It is a lack of respect.

To some extent, I'd say we always "love" the ones we used to love, only that has turned into a different sort of love, and we cannot deny them. Suppose you had a "bad" partner, one who used to shout and drink, or whatever. Even that bad experience has shaped you into what you are now, and hopefully made you better. So even that "bad" partner played a positive role in your life...

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/29/2008 11:55 am

或许有些人会这样做。或许男人不太介意?

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/29/2008 11:53 am

    Quoting dxcxz:
    不包括。了解当前他的思想、品行、对事业、家庭的态度和爱你的程度及为人等等,总之是观察了解你眼前现在的他!
需要一双火眼金睛。

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/29/2008 11:23 am

    Quoting gotofuture1:
    呵呵,感情最好建立在真实的相互了解的基础上。 不是要知道对方有过哪些事,而是对方经历过哪些事以及觉悟,因为那些过程最终槊造现在的ta。 通常遇到什么事,是不可控的,但是,反应和处理却是有规律可循的,你欣赏,你接受或者反感ta的处事, 应该会引导者关系的变化。
    每个人都有些事,自觉光彩的和不光彩的,许多成年人更有失败的婚姻,是否走出过去的阴影,从中觉悟,可以在交流中得知,好的交流,还可以相互提高,觉悟,从而,消除了许多地雷, 如果继续交往的话。
    是否有些道理?
在我看来,不仅非常有道理, 而且讲得非常清楚!谢金牌兄!Can't agree with you any more!

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/29/2008 11:20 am

    Quoting cgy1963:
    这个问题提得好.
    我认为1.不刻意追问,2.不刻意隐瞒,3.情之所至,事之所至,顺其自然,既往不咎.
    如果对方对我的过去有兴趣,愿意倾听,我会毫不保留,如果对方不信任或者计较,我会道一声祝福,默默走开.
    但是,我不会对对方的过去感兴趣,不会刻意去了解对方.
    我以为,了解一个人,了解其基本品质就足够了.了解基本品质其实很容易,比如,对一个人,一件事,一部作品,一种社会现象社会问题的看法,表达的就是我或她的价值取向,道德观念,理想追求,是否有责任感同情心等等.
    对人性人生有基本的正义的认同,才不会迷失.
谢先生来访及留言!您说的有道理。

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

gotofuture1
5861 posts 

10/28/2008 11:57 pm

    Quoting KQRBNP:
    金牌兄,我也认为恋人之间有必要知道一些过去的事情。但这是否会成为两个人关系的基础?
呵呵,感情最好建立在真实的相互了解的基础上。 不是要知道对方有过哪些事,而是对方经历过哪些事以及觉悟,因为那些过程最终槊造现在的ta。 通常遇到什么事,是不可控的,但是,反应和处理却是有规律可循的,你欣赏,你接受或者反感ta的处事, 应该会引导者关系的变化。
每个人都有些事,自觉光彩的和不光彩的,许多成年人更有失败的婚姻,是否走出过去的阴影,从中觉悟,可以在交流中得知,好的交流,还可以相互提高,觉悟,从而,消除了许多地雷, 如果继续交往的话。
是否有些道理?

cgy1963
1914 posts 

10/28/2008 8:16 pm

这个问题提得好.
我认为1.不刻意追问,2.不刻意隐瞒,3.情之所至,事之所至,顺其自然,既往不咎.
如果对方对我的过去有兴趣,愿意倾听,我会毫不保留,如果对方不信任或者计较,我会道一声祝福,默默走开.
但是,我不会对对方的过去感兴趣,不会刻意去了解对方.
我以为,了解一个人,了解其基本品质就足够了.了解基本品质其实很容易,比如,对一个人,一件事,一部作品,一种社会现象社会问题的看法,表达的就是我或她的价值取向,道德观念,理想追求,是否有责任感同情心等等.
对人性人生有基本的正义的认同,才不会迷失.

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/28/2008 10:50 am

    Quoting truelover88:
    This story came from a malaysian friend of mine regarding her aunt. About the virgin part at the wedding night, I did not ask her the detail, I'm not that kind of nosy.
Hahaha..... good for you.

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/28/2008 10:45 am

    Quoting sayhelltouu:
    Very clever question KQ , don't you think that read people's answer itself has had reveal something real information from already ?

    To me, i share your opinion -- i don't care sharing and think it is important. but i also understand those who doesn't seem agree share their past or saying depend on .

    Kindly to think ,none would feel comfortable to tell those of 不堪回首的过去。 why so cruel to uncover their scars ? although ,don't eliminate a few who just want to cheat or pretend ,but i think , majority just don't feel good to mentioned .why don't be kindly to let them easier ?

    I think , take more time to observe and ask some of clever question like this one ,you also can get real info from them bit by bit indirectly and some hurt with directly way may be avoid ?
Absolutely, sayu! I enjoy very much reading people's responses and comments. Especially when you follow some perticular bloggers long enough, it will definitely give you enough information to picture them out.

Not all past are unbearable. 不堪回首。 And it all depends on the person that what, when and how much one want to share with his/her partner. If it's too painful, one can choose not to share. Also, I think it depends on where the two are at the relationship. I've been talking with the person for quite some time and I didn't bother to ask about his past directly until recent. As you said, he often refers something that he experienced in the past in many subjects we talked about without explicitly asked. Actually, my conversation with him over the last weekend triggered me to put this post on. I said to him, "You never said anything about yourself." He said, "You never asked." You see, how funny! We both, in fact, talked and exchanged a lot of information about our lives, now and past. But we never explicitly say "what did you do IN THE PAST?"


Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

meilejia1000
4528 posts 

10/28/2008 9:00 am

不用去了解对方的过去

dxcxz
4215 posts 

10/27/2008 11:32 pm

    Quoting KQRBNP:
    请问先生,在相处中加深了解是否包括了解对方的过去呢?
不包括。了解当前他的思想、品行、对事业、家庭的态度和爱你的程度及为人等等,总之是观察了解你眼前现在的他!

truelover88
531 posts 

10/27/2008 9:54 pm

    Quoting KQRBNP:
    Absolutely agree with you that the mindset and characters play very important role, indeed. What seems odd to me is that the narrow-mind man should try whatever he could to know whether the girl was a virgin before their marriage, or should check immediately after their wedding night. If he tried and did not find it out. What does that mean?
This story came from a malaysian friend of mine regarding her aunt. About the virgin part at the wedding night, I did not ask her the detail, I'm not that kind of nosy.

sayhelltouu
662 posts 

10/27/2008 8:55 pm

Very clever question KQ , don't you think that read people's answer itself has had reveal something real information from already ?

To me, i share your opinion -- i don't care sharing and think it is important. but i also understand those who doesn't seem agree share their past or saying depend on .

Kindly to think ,none would feel comfortable to tell those of 不堪回首的过去。 why so cruel to uncover their scars ? although ,don't eliminate a few who just want to cheat or pretend ,but i think , majority just don't feel good to mentioned .why don't be kindly to let them easier ?

I think , take more time to observe and ask some of clever question like this one ,you also can get real info from them bit by bit indirectly and some hurt with directly way may be avoid ?

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/27/2008 5:15 pm

    Quoting truelover88:
    This is a true story. A very traditional man who in the beginning wants to marry a virgin. He then met a woman and they both fall in love madly and get married. They have 2 kids and live together happily for five years. Somehow he got the wife unintentionally reveal that she was not a virgin before their marriage. This narrow-minded man after knowing the fact became very unhappy within.
    A year later they got divorced. He married another woman but the marriage is not as perfect as the previous one since he still thinks of the previous wife. The previous wife gets married again to a never married man but they live very happily until now. They have 5 grandkids now. This man is a very open minded and an acceptable kind of person. Still this may not apply to any marriage, but somehow the character and the mindset play very important role.
Absolutely agree with you that the mindset and characters play very important role, indeed. What seems odd to me is that the narrow-mind man should try whatever he could to know whether the girl was a virgin before their marriage, or should check immediately after their wedding night. If he tried and did not find it out. What does that mean?

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/27/2008 5:01 pm

    Quoting jpollock:
    I reveal as much as she wishes to know, but I don't volunteer more than she asks. I don't need to know, but sometimes are curious because I fear repeating what caused the problems in the prior relationship.

    jpollock
Jpollock, a very practical method. Does one need to know? Well, as it's said in other comments, it depends on each individual.

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/27/2008 4:53 pm

    Quoting dxcxz:
    我认为没有必要了解过去,重要的是应考虑双方以后能怎样。过去的必竟过去,应从零开始,这样双方相处能自然些,在相处中加深了解,相信自己的眼力和洞察力比盯着对方的过去好的多!
请问先生,在相处中加深了解是否包括了解对方的过去呢?

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!

KQRBNP
5321 posts 

10/27/2008 4:51 pm

    Quoting Mayfromnow:
    了解他(她)的性格,人品和现在远比了解过去重要.了解过去无非就是要了解情史(起因和过程),如果他(她)对你隐瞒或粉饰一些,又能了解多少.相信人品!
哈哈,May,如果他想了解我的情史,大概是要失望了。 你说了很重要的一点 -- 隐瞒与粉饰。 而这正反映出了一个人的人品,是否诚实,是否可相信,不是吗?

Swallow your pride and turn a day of frustration into a day of enlightenment!